I don 't really know what kind of roles Milo used to play since I've only seen Cursed and Gilmore Girls so far. In Gilmore Girls I liked him from the beginning.
I usually like horror movies that are well thought through (but then you'd probably rather call them "mystery thriller" or something) or once in a while the ones that don't take themselves serious. And basically the more it leaves to my imagination the better the movie works for me.